42-46 Elm Street

Architectural Description: 

Stick Style
Gable and mansard roof.

Historical Narrative: 

Themes: Architectural and Community Development

This property was once part of the Valpey estate and purchased by John H. Flint who lived at 8 Elm Street. Flint sold this lot parcel to Andover builder Moody Russell for $800. on Dec. 12, 1872. Russell Built the handsome Eastlake or Stick Style home. The property was then sold to Attie B. Hodgett, of Lawrence, wife of William F. Hodgett. The 1884 map of Andover labeled this home occupied by Albert N. Holt. A large barn occupies the rear yard. 1890 tax list - house valued $2,800, barn $400, 5/8 land, $1,700. Hodgett owned the property for 27 years, and perhaps used it as income property only.

The house was sold to John Hinkey of Andover on Nov. 13, 1907. John later transferred the deed to his wife Hannah in 1923. With the death of Hannah Hinkely the children inherited the property. The deed lists the Hickey heirs: Mary E., Joseph J., John, Andrew F. Hickey, Vincent, Helen R. Young, Catherine McIntosh on March 6, 1936.

Daughter Helen R. Young and her husband William J. Young purchased the house on Sept. 25, 1937. The deed was then transferred to Helen R. on Oct. 31, 1939.
Helen R. Young died on May 4, 1945 and her estate went husband William J. Young. William remarried and the property was deeded to William J. & Flora H. Young on Oct. 14, 1959. With the death of William J. Young, Flora H. Young inherits the property.

On Apr. 19, 1977 Flora H. Young place the property jointly with Edward L. Kershaw of Raleigh, NC. Flora died on Nov. 8, 1981. Edward Kershaw inherited and then sold to
Dennis A. Doherty - Oct. 19, 1982

June 1991 fire in barn

Bibliography/References: 

Essex Country Registry Deeds, Salem, MA
Essex Northern Registry Deeds, Lawrence, MA
Andover Map 1884 atlas - Albert N. Holt

Owners;
Valpey land
John H. Flint - 1872
Moody Russell - Dec. 12, 1872 - b. 57 p. 16 - lot of land
Attie B. Hodgetts, wife of William F. - Apr. 28, 1880 - b. 59 p. 261
John Hickey - Nov. 13, 1907 - b. 225 p. 449
Hannah Hickey - Oct. 19, 1923 - b. 489 p. 168
Hannah Hickey estate, Hickey heirs - Probate
Hickey heirs: Mary E., Joseph J., John, Andrew F. Hickey, Helen R. Young, Catherine McIntosh
Vincent Hickey - Feb. 11, 1936 - b. 597 p. 116
James J. Walsh - March 6, 1936 - b. 597 p. 118
Hickey heirs: Mary E., Joseph J., John, Andrew F. Hickey, Vincent, Helen R. Young, Catherine McIntosh - March 6, 1936 - b. 597 p. 118
William J. & Helen R. Young - Sept. 25, 1937 - b. 610 p. 258
Alan T. Polegreen - Oct. 31, 1939 - b. 626 p. 297 - deed transfer
Helen R. Young - Oct. 31, 1939 - b. 626 p. 297
Helen R. Young estate, heir William J. Young - May 4, 1945 - Probate #213094
Esther M. Dietrich - Oct. 14, 1959 - b. 903 p. 302 - deed transfer
William J. & Flora H. Young - Oct. 14, 1959 - b. 903 p. 304
William J. Young estate, Flora H. Young heir -
Flora H. Young and Edward L. Kershaw - Apr. 19, 1977 - b. b. 1306 p. 226
Flora H. Young estate, heir Edward L. Kershaw - Nov. 8, 1981 -
Dennis A. Doherty - Oct. 19, 1982 - b. 1614 p. 234
Erik P. Doherty - May 3, 2001 - b. 6131 p. 23

Inventory Data:

StreetElm St
PlaceAndover Center
Historic DistrictNot Applicable
Historic NameHodgetts - Hickey House
Present Useresidence - apartments
Original Useresidence
Construction Date1873 - 1880
SourceECRDS, ENRDL, style-njs
Architectural StyleStick
Architect/BuilderMoody Russell builder
Foundationstone/granite/brick
Wall/Trimclapboards/wood
Roofasphalt - hip & gabel
Outbuildings / Secondary Structuressmall clapboarded barn- garage
Major Alterationstwo front bay windows 1960's addition
Conditionexcellent
Acreage0.551 acre, 24,020 sq. ft.; approx. frontage 112 ft.
Settingresidential
Map and parcel38-138
MHC NumberANV.177
Recorded byStack/Mofford, James S. Batchelder
OrganizationAndover Historical Society, Andover Preservation Commission
Date entered1975-77, 2/4/2016

Map: