1 Chestnut Street - Historic Site
Site of History 🛈The Site of History tag is given to properties that were lost before this building survey was undertaken.

Architectural Description: 

The house was modified extensively in 1882 and most likely embraced the Italianate style, deep eaves, brackets.

Historical Narrative: 

The site of the 1961 addition to the St. Augustine School was formerly the location of the Henry G. Tyer homestead which faced on Chestnut Street.

This corner property was once owned by Henry Osgood who sold ¼ acre to Joseph R. Millet on June 17, 1842 for $250. Millet, a master carpenter, then sold the parcel to Benjamin H. Punchard on April 10, 1844 for $300. It appears Punchard built the house as the Geo. Foster 1845 deed of an abutting strip of land, 8 ft. wide, running the depth of the lot states … “adjoining the easterly side of the lot on which said Punchard is now building a house….” Punchard’s home was at 8 High St. facing Elm Sq. Benjamin died on April 4, 1850 and his widow Martha held all the property in her name. The remaining Punchard estate was given, by Will, to the Town of Andover for a Free High School, and several religious organizations who shared a portion of the estate of which this property was included. Additional deeds from the Boston & Main Railroad of the former Andover-Wilmington Railroad which ran along the western edge of the parcel were purchased by abutters.

William Rice purchased the property from the heirs of Punchard’s Will in April 1854 for $4050 but he is also listed here on the 1852 map of Andover. William Rice, wife Lydia M., was a merchant, then sold to Wm. Phillips Foster on May 24,1854 for $6500. Foster held several properties in town including the “Eagle Inn” in Elm Sq. The 1854 map of Andover lists W. Phillips Foster at this location. The 1860 Valuation list of Foster’s properties lists “Rice House and barn, 1 acre lot $4200.”

W. Phillips Foster held for 11 years then sold to Mrs. Elizabeth Tyer, wife of Henry G. Tyer on Oct. 2, 1865 for $6000 In the 1860 census Tyer and family live on No. Main St. near his factory and were probably renting. Henry G. Tyer founded the Tyer Rubber Co. in Andover in 1856, developed and patented the compo shoe design and white rubber process used for pharmaceutical purposes. The first factory was in Ballardvale under the name of North American Patent Shoe Co. in 1856. He partnered briefly with George B. Boice of NJ under the name of Tyer, Boice & Co., then moved the factory to a former Andover & Wilmington Railroad building on North Main St. now the site of the present Andover Public Safety Building. The factory was in operation there until the early 1960's. A larger second plant was later constructed on Railroad St. in 1912.

Henry George Tyer was born on Feb. 23, 1812 in Hackney, England. He was the son of Henry G. and Elizabeth S. (Musgrove) Tyer. Henry married Elizabeth Birch on Sept. 25, 1834 at the Parish of St. Mary Lambeth in Surrey. Elizabeth was the daughter of John & Rebekah Musgrove. Our Musgrove building in Elm Sq. takes its name from this family connection. Henry & Elizabeth had eight children, three born in England; Elizabeth b. 1835, Mary b. 1838 and Henry b. 1840 - d. 1841. The family emigrated to the United States and first settled in New Brunswick, New Jersey where Tyer began his work in rubber production. Here the remaining five children were born, Catherine b. 1842, Horace Henry b. 1844, Frances Anna b. 1847, George Austin b. 1849 and Laura Birch b. 1852.

This home was later owned by his son Horace H. Tyer's as his residence, who took over as president of the company after his father's death. Henry died on July 10, 1882. The 1870 Valuation was 1 acre of land $1600, house $3400, and barn $200. A few months after his father's death Horace began extensive alterations to the house.

October 12, 1882 Andover Advertiser - "H. H. Tyer is raising his residence on Chestnut St. 2½ feet and will put on a new roof. The inside of the house will also be thoroughly remodeled. Charles T. Emerson, architect of Lawrence is the contractor for the job and expects to complete it by the first of January." This corner lot had extensive gardens extending down Central Street and included a barn attached to the rear of the house.

Of the children, Elizabeth, Catherine and George never married. Elizabeth d. in 1912, Catherine d. Nov. 7, 1885, and George died July 4,1877 at age 27 of Typhoid fever in San Francisco, while working for his father's company. Mary married John M. Fiske and lived in Natick. Frances Anna married John H. Flint of Andover, who became Treasurer of Tyer Rubber Co., lived at 8 Elm Square and built the Musgrove Building. Laura Birch Tyer married Frederick W. Thomas.

Son Horace Henry Tyer married Catherine Susan Buss on Sept. 12, 1878 in Medford, MA. Catherine b. Sept. 12, 1854 married on her 24th birthday. She was born in Boston daughter of Samuel L. & Margaret B. Buss. They had four children; Edith Margaret b. 1879, Carrie Elizabeth b. May 20, 1883 d. July 15, 1885 of Diphtheria & Whooping Cough, Henry George II b. Feb. 5, 1885 and Frances Louise b. Aug. 29, 1886. Their son Henry G. Tyer would continue the family connection with his grandfather's company as vice-president until his death in 1947. He married Winifred Hopkins Le Boutillier b. 1900 daughter of Addison Le. Boutillier, architect & designer of Punchard High School and Shawsheen School.

Horace H. Tyer died in 1907. His widow Catherine and daughter Edith continued to live in the house. On July 30, 1913 Catherine sold the property to Thomas M. Smith of Boston. She was unaware that the property was to be used as a Parochial school site and attempted to purchased it back but the sale was complete.

Thomas Smith transferred the property to the St. Mary's Church Society of Lawrence, James J. O'Rielly president. The site would become the first Roman Catholic School in Andover. In 1907 St. Augustine's Parish welcomed the Very Reverend Frederick S. Riordan to the church and it was through his efforts the school was establish. "Not waiting for the school to be erected, the Sisters fitted up the lower floor of their convent into classrooms and began teaching in 1914 on September 8." Sister Helen Bernadine was the first principal serving twice from 1914-1921 and 1927-1931.

The former Tyer house served as a convent for the teaching Nuns of the Order of Notre Dame until 1961. The Tyer mansion was razed to build a new addition to the school building. Mar. 23, 1961 Andover Townsman p3 – Photo - St. Augustine’s demolish house just behind school which was used as a convent.
See Central Street for School History.
May 11, 1917 AT - Contract for the new Parochial School
June 1, 1917 Ground broken for the new Parochial School Monday should be ready by January 1918
Sept. 21, 1917 - Corner stone of St. Augustine’s School laid – Long article and drawing of the school on back page.

The new schoolhouse was formerly opened on September 8, 1918. Fr. Riordan had left several months earlier to become head of a Lawrence parish.


Essex County Registry Deeds, Salem, MA
Essex Northern Registry Deeds, Lawrence, MA
Andover, What it Was, What it Is. 1946
Andover Townsman

Andover maps 1852, 1856, 1872, 1888.

Henry Osgood -
Joseph R. Millet – June 18, 1842 – b. 344 leaf 58 - $250 ¼ acre
Benjamin H. Punchard – Apr. 10, 1844 – b. 344 lf. 59 - $300 ¼ acre
Benj. H. Punchard estate, April 4, 1850 – heirs in Will.
William Rice – April 1854 – b. 495 leaf 229 - $4050
W. Phillips Foster – May 24, 1854 – b. 495 leaf 229 - $6500 w/blds.
Elizabeth Tyer, wife of Henry George Tyer - Oct. 2, 1865 - b. 695 leaf 202 - $6000
Elizabeth Tyer estate, heirs, Elizabeth, Mary, Frances A., Catherine L., Laura B. and Horace H. Tyer, children of Henry & Elizabeth Tyer.
Horace H. Tyer - Aug. 8, 1882 - b. 69 p. 299
Horace H. Tyer from Sophrina A. Gray - second lot Aug. 20, 1883 - b. 73 p. 78
Horace H. Tyer Estate 1907
Heirs, Elizabeth & John W. Savery, Mary T. & John W. Fiske, Frances & John H. Flint, Catherine L. Tyer, and Laura & Frederick W. Thomas. - quit claim to sister.
Catherine L. Tyer - June 20, 1908 - b. 262 p. 181
Thomas M. Smith of Boston - July 30, 1913 - b. 333 p.88
St. Mary's Church Society, Lawrence, MA - July 30, 1913 - b. 333 p. 90
Roman Catholic Archbishop of Boston - Feb. 27, 1917

Inventory Data:

StreetChestnut St
PlaceAndover Center
Historic NameWm. Rice - Henry G. Tyer House
Present UseSt. Augustine's School site
Original Useresidence
Construction Datecirca 1850
Architectural StyleItalianate
Foundationstone & granite
Wall/Trimwood clapboard
Roofcedar shingle
Outbuildings / Secondary StructuresBarn and green house
Major AlterationsHouse raised up 30 inches Demolished in 1961 for addition to St. Augustine's School
Acreage1 acre
Settingresidential/professional offices
Map and parcel55-108
Recorded byJames S. Batchelder
OrganizationAndover Preservation Commission
Date enteredSept. 23, 2014