1 Elm Square
Site of History 🛈The Site of History tag is given to properties that were lost before this building survey was undertaken.

Historical Narrative: 

8 Elm Street – John Flint House – Square & Compass Masonic Lodge
Built 1854 razed 1965

The John Flint mansion was built in the spring and summer of 1854 with a view to Elm Square. Built in the Italianate Style, with heavy brackets accentuating the entablature of the third story attic, the house was one of only a handful of homes to be built of this style in Andover. Before construction could begin Flint’s older residence had to be removed from the site. The mid 18th century house, first owned by John Flint’s father, was lifted off the foundation and moved to 27 Summer Street. On September 16, 1854 AA reports– The house of John Flint, on the village square, is nearly completed and attracts the attention of both town’s people and strangers. The external and internal construction on the building seems to gratify visitors exceedingly.

John Flint Jr. was born in Danvers, now part of Peabody in Feb. 21, 1792. The son of John & Ruth Flint, the Flint’s came to Andover in 1795. John Jr. married on June 6, 1822 to Lydia Clark Abbot b. May 13, 1797, daughter of Abiel & Hannah (Frye) Abbot of Andover.
Children; daughters Hannah Mariah b. Sept. 20, 1824 - d. Apr. 14, 1836, Sarah Abbott b. Sept. 12, 1826 - d. Sept. 15, 1852, Emily Elizabeth b. Nov. 26, 1828 - d. Apr. 17, 1850, Lydia Lucretia b. May 14, 1831, Martha Russell b. July 11, 1833 - d. Aug. 5, 1853, Ann Elizabeth b. Mar. 13, 1835, Hannah Maria b. Nov. 9, 1838, and one son John Henry b. March 6, 1842. John’s wife Lydia died on July 5, 1847 at the age of 50. Flint remarried in 1854 to Mary Ann (Warren) Simpson and then began construction of his new home the same year.

John Flint Jr. was a cabinet maker and carpenter in his early life. He purchased a lot of land of about 7 square rods from Thomas C. Foster on November 13, 1818. This lot at the corner of Main Street & Post Office Ave. came with a deed restriction. He could build and improve the property “except the land north to the old county road as common and never shall be occupied with any buildings or fences nor anything else that shall injure the looks of said common.” John built his cabinet shop on the corner of the Essex Turnpike next to the common in front of the Foster’s Tavern. Construction probably followed in the spring of 1819. Flint sold the property to Benjamin H. Punchard on Nov. 1, 1828 for $2000 which included “the buildings since erected by me”

John Flint had developed an aptitude for accounting and finance and became the first treasurer of the Andover Savings Bank 1834-1870. Also the treasurer for 12 years of the Andover & Wilmington Rail Road incorporated in 1833, later to become the Boston & Maine Railroad. John Flint was a prosperous business man and died June 21, 1873 at the age of 81. Flint’s wife Mary died in 1888.

John Henry was the youngest of the Flint’s children. John H. married Frances Anna Tyer, daughter of Henry George Tyer, the founder of the Tyer Rubber Co., on April 15, 1874 John H. & Frances had two daughters, Gertrude Louisa who married Franklin H. Grier and Nellie Frances who married Joseph A. Rand. John H. became sole owner of his father’s house in April of 1883 and quickly put his mark on the house. June 22, 1883 AA - John Flint put in a bay window over the front door of his house on Elm Square.

John H. was also a successful business man in real estate and the market. He became the president of the Tyer Rubber Co. in 1876-1882 and treasurer from 1882-1914. Flint also served as director and president of the Andover Savings Bank, director of the Andover National Bank and the Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co. He was active in town affairs and served as selectman, assessor, town clerk, treasurer, chairman of the Board of Public Works, Chief of the Fire Department and served on several committees. He was past Master of St. Matthew’s lodge, member of the Andover Lodge of I.O.O.F. and the Andover Club.

Flint purchased the Elm House in June of 1892. The old hotel was no longer a profitable operation and after several meetings with local businessmen Flint sold the building for salvage in April 1894 and began construction of the Musgrove Building on the site of the former common. It is interesting to note that he was somehow able to build on the very common that both Thomas C. Foster and his father John Flint had placed a deed restriction on years before.

John H. Flint died Nov. 30, 1916 and his wife and daughters inherited the properties. The Musgrove Building was sold to Louis & Samuel Resnik on Sept. 27, 1920. Frances Flint died on March 22, 1922, daughters Nellie and Gertrude then sold the Flint mansion to Building Trustees of St. Mathew’s Lodge A.F. & A.M. of Andover, MA on Sept. 28, 1922.

The building committee trustees consisted of Albert W. Lowe the Worshipful Master of the lodge, Walter H. Thompson, Henry A. Bodwell and William Odlin. On November 17, 1922 a general meeting was called in the lodge room and 69 men signed applications for membership. The new lodge was first called “The Masonic Club of Andover, Mass.” but was later changed to the “Andover Square and Compass Club”.

The house became comfortable quarters for the lodge and opened for inspection on January 1, 1923. The rooms provided a reading room, card rooms, billiard hall, reception parlor and committee rooms. The former Flint barn to the rear of the property was converted into an assembly and function hall equipped with a kitchen, serving counters and tables. June 3, 1927 AT - Square & Compass Club New assembly hall opens in the Flint Barn on June 2. This hall was used by several community organizations including the “Eastern Star Chapter” and the “Thimble Club”, an organization of the women of several of the fraternal members. The town used the hall as a polling place for several years and in 1944 it became the meeting place for “Clan Johnson, No. 185, Order of Scottish Clans”. The Andover Chapter of the American Red Cross used the club briefly in the early 1950’s.

October 27, 1963 the members of St. Mathews Lodge at a special meeting elected, Robert B. Parker, Raeburn B. Hathaway, J. Elwyn Russell, Warren A. Maddox and R. Kingman Webster as Building Trustees of said lodge and were instructed to sell the property. “The consideration for said conveyance being the construction of a new Masonic Temple on lot B as shown on plan”

The property was divided and a new lodge erected to the rear of the property fronting on High Street. The remaining parcel with the house and hall were sold on July 10, 1964 to Danton Realty Trust. The Realty Company was partnered by L. John Davidson, Phidias G. Dantos and Urville J. Beaumont. The former Flint Mansion and Masonic lodge buildings were razed in April of 1965 for the construction of the modern brick office building that became known as the Standard International Building the first tenants. Originally Standex International the name was changed to Standard International Corporation of Ohio in 1973.

Danton Realty sold the property the “Trustees of Village Improvement Realty Trust” on April 18, 1968; Warren S. Cooper, Donald Junior and Peter S. Manke, trustees. Standard International then purchased the building in 1971. Software International formerly Geisub II Corporation of Delaware acquired the property in Sept. of 1980 and sold to Elm Square Realty Trust in 1983. The building was then renames One Elm Square and the office building was divided in office condominiums.

Dec. 23, 1965 AT – p. 8 Photos of Main Street – Library addition from location of Standard International & Town Yard.


Essex County Registry Deeds, Salem, MA
Essex Northern Registry Deeds, Lawrence, MA
Andover Advertiser
Andover Townsman

Benjamin Ames Jr. 1801 ("former James Parker estate")
John Flint - Dec. 8, 1801 - b. 169 leaf 191 - $600. - 2 parcels
John Flint Jr. - 1854 - built house
John Flint estate, died June 21, 1873
John Henry Flint - April 11, 1883 - b. 71 p. 148 release
John Henry Flint - died Nov. 30, 1916, heirs, Frances, Nellie, & Gertrude
Nellie F. Rand - Feb. 13, 1917 - b. 373 p. 41 Agent
Frances A. Flint - Feb. 13, 1917 - b. 373 p. 190
Frances A. Flint estate, heirs Nellie F. Rand & Gertrude L. Grier - Dec. 30, 1922 - b. 471 p. 158 Plan #489
Building Trustees of St. Mathew’s Lodge AF & AM of Andover, MA - Sept. 28, 1922 - b. 466 p. 418
Danton Realty Trust - July 10, 1964 - b. 1013 p. 415 - Plan #4951
(L. John Davidson, Phidius G. Dantos & Urville J. Beaumont)
Trustees of Village Improvement Realty Trust - Apr. 18, 1968 - b. 1104 p. 185
Standex International Corp. - June 23, 1971 - b. 1174 p. 620
Standard International Corp. - June 21, 1974 - b. 1243 p. 436 name changed
Software International Corp. - Sept. 23, 1980 - b. 1456 p. 135
Geisub II Corp. - Oct. 1, 1981 - b. 1537 p. 286
Elm Square Realty Trust - Dec. 14, 1983 - b. 1629 p. 31
Elm Square Realty Trust - Aug. 23, 1983 - b. 1721 p. 222 master deed
Elm Square Condominiums - Plan #9251
“One Elm Square” now twenty multi business condominiums

Inventory Data:

StreetElm Sq
PlaceAndover Center
Historic NameJohn H. & Frances A. Flint house / Square & Compas building
Present UseOffice building
Original Useresidence
Construction Date1854
SourceECRDS, ENRDL, style-njs
Architectural StyleItalianate
Roofasphalt - low hip
Demolition DetailsApril 1965
Map and parcel38-117
Recorded byJames S. Batchelder
OrganizationAndover Preservation Commission
Date enteredFeb. 25, 2016