10 - 12 Brechin Terrace

Architectural Description: 

Shingle Style

Historical Narrative: 

Brechin Terrace
Brechin Terrace was developed by the Smith & Dove Manufacturing Co. when Peter Dove Smith was the President of the company and John Smith’s grandson George F. Smith the manager. Plans were announced in the summer of 1907 that the company was to expand its warehouse. The plans also included tenement housing and a large boarding house to be erected in the future on the Cogswell estate at 29 Shawsheen Road. John Ashton architect for Lawrence and E. W. Pitman builder

July 12, 1907 AT A Mill And Its People ….. the Smith & Dove Mfg. Co. are building a most attractive mill village over on what has long been known as the “Cogswell estate”.
In the rearrangement of old houses and the construction of new houses, about thirty tenements are to be provided in this new layout. The land upon which these new buildings are being constructed is rich in all that has made the rare history of old Andover. The old ancestral Cogswell house stands as a sentinel at the brow of the hill, and the field in which the new houses are to be built awakens many suggestions of the broad acres that so often marked the old-time New England H=homestead. The new development in this field includes a roadway stretching from the main highway a distance of 400 feet to the north, having in its center a greensward to be made a landscape feature of the attractive court that will furnish an entrance to the thirteen new double houses. The houses are located on either side of the court and are modern houses, providing tenements of six rooms and a bath in each. The architecture of the houses is so designed that they shall be restful to the artistic eye, while sufficiently simple in their construction as to be economical in the matter of repairs and maintenance. The lay of the land is such that perfect sanitary conditions will be provided, and nothing is to be spared in the entire construction to make of them most desirable homes which the rental in reach of the most modest income.
One can hardly appreciate the beauty of the surroundings of these new houses. The Shawsheen at its most attractive part centres in the valley below and a clear and unobstructed view is had across the valley, of the town to the east. …… The Smith & Dove Co., and somewhat of the individual force that is carrying it out,, it is a pleasure to here recognize the success and the ability and foresight that is so marked in it in the person of its active manager, Mr. George F. Smith. …..

Nov. 29, 1907 AT p5 – “From An Andover Window – Lights are twinkling from the new houses on Cogswell’s Hill. Thanksgiving dinners were eaten yesterday for the first time on the Commonwealth Avenue of the Abbott Village. As I trudged up the hill in the gloaming, on my way out to West Parish, I halted at the new street and pleased myself with the appetizing odors of the recent festal meals, with the cheerful lights, with the nice houses. The walk up Cogswell’s Hill is longer than it used to be; for the new street and the big boarding- house have ruined one of the prettiest of Andover views, down to the Shawsheen valley to Marland Village. But what must be, must be; and this is one of the “must bes.” And since it was so, let us be thankful for what remains. Very hearty thanks, more over, are due Mr. George Smith for the skill and taste and enlightened ideas which he has shown in the building of these cottages. It is still possible to build factory houses so cheap and so hideous that the little converted farmhouses of the older parts of Abbott Village and the tiny abodes of Marland Village are architectural gens in comparison. Contrasted with any of these, the cottages of the new street are a delight both to the housekeeper and to the spectator. Among the special town blessings of the year, I would give high place to the public spirit of the Smith & Dove Company, when Commonwealth Avenue was designed.”

Jan. 6, 1911 At – Ian McDougall - McDougall’s Musings – Taking Stock – Perhaps after all is said, it may be that the greatest improvement has been brought about by the building of the nice workingman’s houses by the good firm here – Red Spring road houses, the Essex street tenements and then to crown all, the fine Brechin Terrace cottages, good enough for President Taft or any man or woman to live in. ….. I wish now to get a name for what as I am told, they now call the fine houses at the bridge on Essex Street, and instead of “new tenements,” I wish them called “Brothock Cresent.” Brechin Terrace is right, as it puts one in mind of the Scotchman who was the founder of the company….
The Cottages were rented to operatives and families of the Smith & Dove Mill but also to families employed in the Marland and Tyer Rubber Companies too. In the 1908 Andover resident directory residents occupied 1-3, 5-7, 13 and 25 and on the north were 2-4, 6-8, 10 and 24-26. This suggests that as the apartments were completed residents moved in.

The houses were built to look like single family homes but are actually two family townhouses side by side in mirror image floor plan layout. The gambrel roofs contain the second floor bedrooms and bath with an additional room for each unit in the attic space, one facing the front and the other unit having the rear view. Thirteen houses were constructed on what was first called Commonwealth Ave. and then changed to Brechin Terrace for the birthplace in Scotland of both John & Peter Smith. The broad avenue had a small island strip down middle with shade trees planted in a long row. Additional trees were planted in front of each house. In time the island was removed.

Smith & Dove recognized the need for operative housing and slowly acquired several homes in the immediate area. They built quality housing for their working force at 62-84 Essex St. and the double homes on Brechin Terrace. Every home on Baker Lane was once owned by Smith & Dove.
The company reorganized in 1864 and again in 1912 bringing all their properties together into one deed.
The company supplied their workers with a Village Hall (#79 Essex St.) for community gatherings, and built “Hillside” on Shawsheen Rd. for single women workers; provided childcare service, bowling alley, laundry and large dining room used for meetings and parities. S & D Co. also bought the old Cricket Field for the company soccer, football and baseball teams and sponsored many field day outings for their employees.

In 1927 the Smith & Dove Co. was sold to the Ludlow Co. All their housing real estate was placed in the Smith & Dove Tenements, Inc. that year, later changing the name to Andover Homes, Inc. in Jan. 1928. The company operations were moved to Ludlow, MA and the mill closed in 1928. The houses were then sold off into private hands. With the stock market crash in 1929 and the Depression that followed, many homes were not sold and were vacant. In June 1932 Virgil D. Harrington took over management sales of the remaining houses on the terrace.

Emile R. & Gertrude R. Dufresne purchased the now vacant house from Harrington on Oct. 7, 1932. Dufresne in 1943 worked in sales for H. P. Hood & Sons the large milk company. They operated a store at #42 Main Street. Pauline Dufresne is also listed in the home at #5 which is #10 today. The Dufresne family owned the property until 1954 or 22 years.

The early Andover directories of Brechin Terrace list all the houses on the left side of the street as 1 - 12 and on the right as 13 - 26 in an order as if delivering mail. Beginning with #1 on the left and walking down the left side turning at the end and moving back up the right side with 13 at the east end of the street and #26 at the corner of Shawsheen Rd. Toady all even numbers are on the left and all odd numbers are on the right. This is now true for every street in town.

William J. & Louise A. Stewart purchased the house on Mar. 25, 1954 and had lived there for 22 years when William died July 27, 1976. Widow Louise Stewart sold a year later to Robert J. & Mary Lou Dawson on June 23, 1977. Mary Lou Dawson held the deed in 1979.
Constance A. Grant purchased the property from Dawson in May 1984 and held for 16 years then sold to Robert J. Moore on Mar. 16, 2000.
Moore sells just two years later to Jenny S. Eng & Stephen K. Eng - May 31, 2002 and Eng to Richard N. Mazzarese - Mar. 1, 2011
who placed the property into a trust named 10 -12 Brechin Terr. Realty Trust.


Essex County Registry Deeds, Salem, MA
Essex Northern Registry Deeds, Lawrence, MA
Andover Townsman
Andover Street Directories – 1908, 1913, 1930
See Maps #886 Clark 1932 and #676 Smith & Dove 1927

Smith & Dove Manufacturing Co. deed changes in 1864 and 1912
Smith & Dove Manufacturing Co., Geo. F. Smith, Pres. - Feb. 1, 1927 - b. 529 p. 587
Smith & Dove Tenements, Inc. Geo. Endicott, Pres., - Feb. 21, 1927 - b. 529 p. 583
Andover Homes, Inc., Jan. 3, 1928 – b. 538 p. 356 Name change cert.
Virgil D. Harrington – June 7, 1932 - b. 564 p. 546
Emile R. & Gertrude R. Dufresne - Oct. 7, 1932 - b. 566 p. 542
William J. & Louise A. Stewart - Mar. 25, 1954 - b. 789 p. 208
Louise A. Stewart, heir, William died July 27, 1976
Robert J. & Mary Lou Dawson - June 23, 1977 - b. 1311 p. 553
Mary Lou Dawson - Sept. 7, 1979 - b. 1389 p. 159
Constance A. Grant - May 11, 1984 - b. 1807 p. 264
Robert J. Moore - Mar. 16, 2000 - b. 5702 p. 193
Jenny S. Eng & Stephen K. Eng - May 31, 2002 - b. 6859 p. 144
Stephen K. Eng - June 23, 2010 - b. 12079 p. 106
Richard N. Mazzarese - Mar. 1, 2011 - b. 12426 p. 106
10 -12 Brechin Terr. Realty Trust, Mazzarese Tr. - Mar. 16, 2011 - b. 12436 p. 167

Inventory Data:

StreetBrechin Tr
PlaceAbbott Village
Historic DistrictAndover Village Industrial NRH District
Historic NameSmith & Dove Manf. Co. - Two Family Housing
Present Useresidences - 2 family
Original Useresidence - mill housing
Construction Date1907
Architectural StyleShingle
Architect/BuilderJohn Ashton architect/E. W. Pitman builders
Wall/Trimclapboards/vinyl covered
Outbuildings / Secondary Structuresgarage
Acreage0.172 A
Map and parcel54-29
Recorded byStack/Mofford, James Batchelder
OrganizationAndover Preservation Commission
Date entered1975-77, 7/2014